DMARC fail despite SPF pass and DKIM pass
The headers show the SPF/DKIM credited, but the DMARC still does not pass. DMARC requires domain compatibility in From with domain used by SPF or DKIM; the pass results themselves are not sufficient.
How to determine the source of the error
Check From address, Return-Path domain and signature d= for DKIM.
Read the dmarc domain record and adkim/aspf settings, distinguishing compatibility relaxed from strict.
What to do step by step
1. Configure the supplier so that at least one authentication mechanism is consistent with From domain. If the supplier sends through a technical domain, configure your own signature domain according to From address.
2 . Monitor DMARC reports before tightening your policy so as not to block legal broadcasters.
How to check the score
The test message shows dmarc=pass and compatibility with the actual broadcast domain.
What to do
Do not set p=reject immediately if you do not have a full list of mailing systems.