VAT refund with 8% sales and 23% purchases — a PLN 50,000 example
Selling at 8% VAT while buying at 23% can create excess deductible input VAT. That is not a free profit. The answer depends on whether amounts are gross or net, whether input VAT is deductible, and the entire VAT return for the period.
Educational calculator
Calculate VAT for your own amounts
Change the amounts and choose net or gross. This illustration assumes sales at 8% and purchases at 23%, with full entitlement to deduct input VAT.
| Sales 8% | Purchases 23% | |
|---|---|---|
| Gross | 50,000.00 zł | 50,000.00 zł |
| Net | 46,296.30 zł | 40,650.41 zł |
| VAT | 3,703.70 zł | 9,349.59 zł |
Potential excess input VAT
5,645.89 zł
Net margin before other expenses
5,645.89 zł
This models two transactions only. Excess VAT does not guarantee a refund; deduction rules, the full return and tax authority verification apply. This is not personalized tax advice.
First distinguish gross from net
At 8% VAT, PLN 50,000 gross means PLN 50,000 / 1.08 = PLN 46,296.30 net and PLN 3,703.70 output VAT. At 23%, PLN 50,000 gross on purchases means PLN 40,650.41 net and PLN 9,349.59 input VAT.
To extract VAT from a gross price, divide by 1 plus the VAT rate. Never just subtract 8% or 23% of the gross price.
Scenario A: PLN 50,000 gross in sales and purchases
Sales: PLN 46,296.30 net plus PLN 3,703.70 VAT equals PLN 50,000 gross. Purchases: PLN 40,650.41 net plus PLN 9,349.59 VAT equals PLN 50,000 gross.
Excess input VAT is PLN 9,349.59 − PLN 3,703.70 = PLN 5,645.89, provided full deduction is allowed. The amount must be considered together with other items in the VAT return.
The net margin on these two items is also PLN 5,645.89 before other costs. A VAT refund is not extra profit on top of that margin.
Scenario B: PLN 50,000 net in sales and purchases
Sales: PLN 50,000 net + PLN 4,000 VAT = PLN 54,000 gross. Purchases: PLN 50,000 net + PLN 11,500 VAT = PLN 61,500 gross.
The excess input VAT is PLN 7,500, while the net margin on these two items is zero. A potential refund offsets the gross cash-flow difference; it does not create PLN 7,500 of earnings.
Real figures can differ when input VAT is only partially deductible, other invoices are included, or adjustments apply.
When can a business claim a refund?
Generally a business must be an active VAT taxpayer, have purchases used for taxable activity, and meet statutory deduction requirements. Not all expenses qualify; the entire reporting period matters.
For reporting periods starting on or after 1 February 2026, the ordinary Polish refund period is 40 days after submitting JPK_VAT with the declaration. Special periods apply and verification can extend the payment date. The credit may also be carried forward.
An 8% sale does not itself guarantee a tax refund. Both the reduced sale rate and input VAT deduction must be properly supported.
Mistakes worth avoiding
Do not assume that every consumer service or every installation is taxed at 8%. Do not confuse the 5.5% lump-sum income tax rate for certain construction services with VAT. Do not treat a VAT refund as profit.
Check the nature of the supply, invoice documentation and deduction rules. A Polish Binding Rate Information decision (WIS) may help establish a VAT rate; case-specific tax advice should come from an authorized professional.